Electric Utilities Achieve Highest Level of Business Customer Satisfaction since 2009

Press release from the issuing company

Tuesday, January 27th, 2015

Business customer satisfaction with their electric utility has hit its highest mark since 2009, based primarily on a substantial year-over-year increase in satisfaction with power quality and reliability, which, in turn, is driven by a significant improvement in utilities' efforts to provide more accurate outage information, according to the J.D. Power 2015 Electric Utility Business Customer Satisfaction StudySM  released today.       

The study measures satisfaction among business customers of 101 U.S. electric utilities, each of which serves more than 25,000 business customers. In aggregate, these utilities provide electricity to more than 12 million customers. Overall satisfaction is examined across six factors (listed in order of importance): power quality and reliability; billing and payment; corporate citizenship; price; communications; and customer service. Satisfaction is calculated on a 1,000-point scale.

Reaching its highest score in the past seven years, overall satisfaction among electric utility business customers is 677 in 2015, compared with 617 in 2009—a significant 60-point increase. Additionally, satisfaction increases by 15 points from 2014 (662). Performance improvement in 2015 is driven by a sharp year-over-year rise in satisfaction with power quality and reliability (+19 points), which is bolstered by a notable improvement in utilities' efforts to provide more accurate information about outages. 

In addition, this is the second consecutive year of improvement for more than 80 percent of the electric utilities included in the study, regardless of whether they rank among the highest- or lowest-performing companies. 

"It's important to note that many electric utilities that have traditionally ranked at the low end of the overall index now include in their business goals initiatives that are aimed at improving customer satisfaction," said Andrew Heath, director of the energy practice at J.D. Power. "Among those utilities, several are posting substantial increases in satisfaction as a result. When utilities highly satisfy its customer base, there is a quantifiable positive impact on profitability and credit ratings for the utility."

KEY FINDINGS 

  • Power quality and reliability satisfaction among business customers who receive outage information (713) is 143 points higher than among those who do not receive such outage information (570).  
  • Utility communications positively impact satisfaction. Overall communications satisfaction among customers who recall receiving a communication from their utility is 74 points higher than among those who do not recall any communication. The percentage of business customers recalling a communication from their utility has increased to 55 percent in 2015 from 51 percent in 2014.
  • Online account setup among business customers has grown to 57 percent in 2015 from 33 percent in 2009. Nearly three-fourths (72%) of business customers resolve their problem or issue online during the first contact, compared with 69 percent of those who resolve their problem by phone during the first contact.
  • Overall satisfaction is highest among industrial business customers (682) and lowest among healthcare customers (675).

Study Rankings
Within each of the four geographic regions included in the study, utility providers are classified into one of two segments: large (serving 85,000 or more business customers) and midsize (serving between 25,000 and 84,999 business customers). Rankings within each region and segment are as follows:

East Region
PSE&G ranks highest among large electric utility providers in the East Region, with a score of 685. Among midsize electric utilities in the East Region, Delmarva Power ranks highest with a score of 691.

Midwest Region
In the Midwest Region, MidAmerican Energy (718) ranks highest among large electric utilities for a second consecutive year. Omaha Public Power District (728) ranks highest among midsize utilities. 

South Region
Georgia Power (731) ranks highest among large utilities in the South Region for a third consecutive year. Among midsize electric utilities, Gulf Power ranks highest (731).

West Region
SRP (Salt River Project) ranks highest among large electric utilities in the West Region for a second consecutive year, with a score of 741. Among midsize electric utility providers, Seattle City Light ranks highest with a score of 716.

The 2015 Electric Utility Business Customer Satisfaction Study is based on responses from 22,857 online interviews with business customers who spend at least $200 monthly on electricity. The study was fielded from April through June 2014 and July through November 2014.

Overall Customer Satisfaction Index Scores    
   
  (Based on a 1,000-point scale)                   

East Region: Large Segment

PSE&G                           

685

PPL Electric Utilities         

681

Con Edison                       

671

National Grid                      

663

NYSEG                              

662

BGE                                   

660

East Large Segment Average 

659

NSTAR                                 

651

Jersey Central Power & Light   

649

PECO                                     

644

Appalachian Power                   

642

Connecticut Light & Power         

626

PSEG Long Island                      

595

          

East Region: Midsize Segment

Delmarva Power           

691

United Illuminating         

689

Rochester Gas & Electric   

659

Duquesne Light                  

654

Met-Ed                               

654

Central Maine Power            

652

Penelec                               

646

East Midsize Segment Average    

644

Public Service of New Hampshire   

639

West Penn Power                         

639

Pepco                                           

635

Atlantic City Electric                       

619

   

Note: Included in the study, but not ranked due to insufficient sample size are Central Hudson Gas & Electric, Green Mountain Power, Mon Power, Orange & Rockland and Potomac Edison.

 

Midwest Region: Large Segment

MidAmerican Energy                

718

Xcel Energy-Midwest                

705

KCP&L                                    

699

DTE Energy                              

693

We Energies                              

692

Consumers Energy                      

681

Midwest Large Segment Average   

680

Ohio Edison                                  

678

Duke Energy-Midwest                     

676

Alliant Energy                                 

675

Ameren Illinois                                 

674

Ameren Missouri                              

666

ComEd                                             

664

AEP Ohio                                          

655

 

Midwest Region: Midsize Segment

Omaha Public Power District        

728

WPS                                           

699

Indianapolis Power & Light             

691

Indiana Michigan Power                  

690

Kentucky Utilities                            

686

Dayton Power & Light                       

681

Midwest Midsize Segment Average     

674

Louisville Gas & Electric                     

670

Westar Energy                                   

665

The Illuminating Company                    

659

NIPSCO                                              

612

   

Note: Included in the study, but not ranked due to insufficient sample size are Empire District Electric and Toledo Edison.   

              

South Region: Large Segment             

 

Georgia Power                              

731

Alabama Power                             

729

OG&E                                           

723

Entergy Arkansas                           

706

Florida Power & Light                       

700

South Large Segment Average           

698

Entergy Louisiana                              

696

Dominion Virginia Power                    

691

South Carolina Electric & Gas             

687

Duke Energy-Carolinas                        

678

Duke Energy-Progress                         

672

Duke Energy-Florida                             

667

                

South Region: Midsize Segment

Gulf Power                      

731

Entergy Mississippi          

722

Entergy Texas                  

711

CPS Energy                      

707

JEA                                   

705

Public Service Co. of Oklahoma  

692

South Midsize Segment Average 

689

OUC                                          

684

Austin Energy                             

677

NES                                            

657

Tampa Electric                              

655

MLGW                                          

623

   

Note: Included in the study, but not ranked due to insufficient sample size are Cleco Power, Mississippi Power, Santee Cooper, Southwestern Electric Power and Xcel Energy-South.                

                

West Region: Large Segment

SRP                                               

741

Portland General Electric                  

703

APS                                                

702

Pacific Power                                    

692

Rocky Mountain Power                       

684

NV Energy                                          

680

Southern California Edison                    

678

Xcel Energy-West                                

677

West Large Segment Average               

677

San Diego Gas & Electric                      

671

Puget Sound Energy                             

667

Pacific Gas and Electric                         

664

L.A. Dept. of Water & Power                 

646

                

West Region: Midsize Segment

Seattle City Light                   

716

SMUD                                  

713

Avista                                    

704

West Midsize Segment Average 

691

Idaho Power                               

685

PNM                                          

684

NorthWestern Energy                   

679

Tucson Electric Power                   

678